counter
about us
 
For Us, The Living: A Comedy of Customs | Robert A. Heinlein | Thinly veiled, but worthwhile.
 
 


Suche books:   



 For Us, The Living...  

For Us, The Living: A Comedy of Customs
Robert A. Heinlein

Pocket, 2004 - 352 pages

average customer review:based on 53 reviews
view larger image
 for more information click here

 



From Grandmaster Robert A. Heinlein comes a long-lost first novel, written in 1939 and never before published, introducing ideas and themes that would shape his career and define the genre that is synonymous with his name.

July 12, 1939Perry Nelson is driving along the palisades when suddenly another vehicle swerves into his lane, a tire blows out, and his car careens off the road and over a bluff. The last thing he sees before his head connects with the boulders below is a girl in a green bathing suit, prancing along the shore....

When he wakes, the girl in green is a woman dressed in furs and the sun-drenched shore has transformed into snowcapped mountains. The woman, Diana, rescues Perry from the bitter cold and takes him inside her home to rest and recuperate.

Later they debate the cause of the accident, for Diana is unfamiliar with the concept of a tire blowout and Perry cannot comprehend snowfall in mid-July. Then Diana shares with him a vital piece of information: The date is now January 7. The year...2086.

When his shock subsides, Perry begins an exhaustive study of global evolution over the past 150 years. He learns, among other things, that a United Europe was formed and led by Edward, Duke of Windsor; former New York City mayor LaGuardia served two terms as president of the United States; the military draft was completely reconceived; banks became publicly owned and operated; and in the year 2003, two helicopters destroyed the island of Manhattan in a galvanizing act of war. This education in the ways of the modern world emboldens Perry to assimilate to life in the twenty-first century.

But education brings with it inescapable truths -- the economic and legal systems, the government, and even the dynamic between men and women remain alien to Perry, the customs of the new day continually testing his mental and emotional resolve. Yet it is precisely his knowledge of a bygone era that will serve Perry best, as the man from 1939 seems destined to lead his newfound peers even further into the future than they could have imagined.

A classic example of the future history that Robert Heinlein popularized during his career, For Us, The Living marks both the beginning and the end of an extraordinary arc of political, social, and literary crusading that comprises his legacy. Heinlein could not have known in 1939 how the world would change over the course of one and a half centuries, but we have our own true world history to compare with his brilliant imaginings, rendering For Us, The Living not merely a novel, but a time capsule view into our past, our present, and perhaps our future.

The novel is presented here with an introduction by acclaimed science fiction writer Spider Robinson and an afterword by Professor Robert James of the Heinlein Society.


 for more information click here


Amazingly Current

I'm a die hard Heinlein fan, but regardless I'm impressed how current this book feels. Sure, it's more of a lecture on customs (see the title) than a novel with a convoluted plot, but the ideas are very interesting... it seems that mankind hasn't evolved that much in 80 years from 1938. Well worth the read, a definite treat for Heinlein fans, and highly recommended, especially for people of Libertarian and/ or Objectivist persuasion.


Thinly veiled, but worthwhile.

Other reviews go much deeper into the technical aspects of this work, but simply: "For Us, The Living" is worth a read.

You have to understand before reading the book that it really is a very thinly veiled political treatise written under the guise of a Sci-Fi a novel. Many reviewers simply write the work off on this point, but these people just aren't good students of history. Many great thinkers back to our first major written accounts of critical thinking- including Plato, for example- wrote in this same general form. You can disagree with the content, but the form is entirely valid.

So the basic story of "For Us, The Living" is nearly unimportant. It is a fairly light tale wherein a citizen of the early 20th century is thrown into an established 21st century. He feels regret, he falls in love, he chases his dreams. If you were to hack out the political musings and keep only this portion of the novel, you'd have a pretty forgettable short story.

But it's the political aspect that makes this book tick- much like Heinlein's later works, such as Starship Troopers. Heinlein will go on for pages describing his idea of a political near-Utopia (though he's quick to caution he understands true perfection is impossible). Citizens enjoy broad personal freedoms under a completely reformed economic system that is almost totally alien in comparison to anything except Socialism. This provides a stark contrast to works like Starship Troopers- in Troopers, you'd be forgiven for thinking Heinlein was one of the world's staunchest conservative thinkers. Here, we see an almost entirely liberal take on society, reform, and social welfare.

Everyone is quick to find faults with the political commentary in this work. Economists strain to point out how his proposed economic system wouldn't work. Politicians try to point out how his system isn't feasible. Bankers more than likely try to write off this work entirely. But if you come in with an open mind and not just a will to try to prove the book wrong, you can at least enjoy the fact that Heinlein's proposed political ideas are eons ahead of their time. Some of his ideas have actually come largely to pass, such as Americans being able to work from their homes without driving to an office. Some of the concerns he raises, such as the Libertarian-esque concern that banks have too much control over the world economy, are just as relevant today as they were then.

Above all, this book is just worth reading. Go in with an open mind, and at least consider some of his ideas. If you think he's wrong, he challenges you to prove that he's wrong. Characters in the book repeatedly note that they want you (as the main character) to prove them wrong and to challenge their ideas. Even if you wind up disagreeing with the whole lot of his thinking and poking holes in every aspect of his commentary, you'll be a better person for the mental exercise, and that's a very valuable thing to gain from a work that would otherwise be a content-light short story.


 for more information click here


Worst vs best

The very worst that RAH would ever do is better than 90% of what is out there. Is this one of his best? Simply, no. Is it a good book? Yes when judged against most other writers. Certainly not the book to use as an introduction to Heinlein. When I heard about this book I was very excited. Having already read all his books (more than once) the prospect of something Id not read was almost beyond belief. Having read several negative reviews. my expectations were lowered. It was a lot better than what I hand expected and not as good as I had hoped. I am very happy to have read it but would probably recommended it for Heinlein fans only


 for more information click here


Don't make this your first Heinlein read.

Like the title says, don't make this your first Heinlein read, or even your second. My only experience with Heinlein before reading this was Starship Troopers(loved it) and this book almost turned me off completely to Heinlein. After reading reviews of the book i came to understand that this book is not the norm for the author and isn't really representative of his work as a whole.
Steer clear until you've read some of his other work or possibly just ignore it all together unless you absolutely must read all of his books.


An interesting Utopia

I picked this book up at the library after having read Heinlein's Moon is a Harsh Mistress and enjoying it. I was pleasantly surprised to find that it described a future society that one imagines is Heinein's pragmatic Utopia (though he does say it isn't Utopia.) I had read More's Utopia and Huxley's Brave New World this summer and this ended up fitting well into my personal reading series.

I found it to be full of interesting ideas--most of which I didn't agree with, but which were definitely provided food for thought. Here are some of my critiques. Clothes are optional in this world--for every person I'd like to see naked there are 10 I am glad that are clothed; plus I think it is easier to wear clothes than to have to constantly maintain and groom a naked body. The economic system is described in detail and is quite intriguing. However, I am not convinced that it would work unless you are in a closed system with limited contact with other economies. Still, it was really interesting to read the ideas and wrestle with them as a thought exercise. I prefer Heinlein's sexual mores to Huxley--at least in Heinlein's world sexual activity takes place in the context of relationship, rather than merely casual hookups. Still, I thought that Heinlein projected his own marital dissatisfaction onto the entire institution. I am happily married and know many others in the same boat. I like the security and commitment that a marriage relationship offers. In Heinlein's world, it would seem less likely to have someone be willing to stand by you when everything went south if there was not a similar commitment. Also, I think that his ideas come from a male perspective and are a veneer to allow for multiple partners. However, in some ways the relationships he describes are a de facto description of many people's relationships today. He also assumed that syphilis and gonnohorrea were eradicated, allowing for greater promiscuity without consequence. I doubt that the future will ever be completely free of STDs.

Whether you like his ideas or not, they are powerful enough to demand that you grapple with them and give you a lot to chew over.


 for more information click here


reviews: page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10



products you might be interested in




recommendations

Locus 2004 Recommended Reading in SciFi
Mr. R. Heinlein, Ahead of His Time
Read by Paul in 2005




customs


The Woman Warrior: Memoirs of a Girlhood Among Ghosts
Rules of the Game
The Secret
Why Men Love Bitches: From Doormat to Dreamgirl-A Woman's Guide to ...
The Anglo Files: A Field Guide to the British



living


Breakthrough: Eight Steps to Wellness
Render Unto Caesar: Serving the Nation by Living our Catholic Beliefs ...
Living Dead in Dallas (Southern Vampire Mysteries, Book 2)
You: Staying Young: The Owner's Manual for Extending Your Warranty ...
The Secret



search for books
for us the, comedy, customs, living



Google      toavi.com    web
books
apparel
baby
beauty
books
camera photo
classical music
computers
dvd
electronics
gourmet food
health personal care
kitchen
office products
outdoor living
computer video games
popular music
software
sporting goods
tools hardware
toys-games
vhs
watches jewelry







randomly chosen


music: The King of Rock 'n' Roll: The Complete 50's Masters