counter
about us
 
A Different Universe: Reinventing Physics from the Bottom Down | Robert Laughlin | Why do they love it and hate it?
 
 


Suche books:   



 Up (Four-Disc Blu-...   Broderbund 3D Home...   Othmar Muller   One Night In March...   A Different Univer...  

A Different Universe: Reinventing Physics from the Bottom Down
Robert Laughlin

Basic Books, 2005 - 272 pages

average customer review:based on 33 reviews
view larger image
 for more information click here

 



Why everything we think about fundamental physical laws needs to change, and why the greatest mysteries of physics are not at the ends of the universe but as close as the nearest ice cube or grain of salt.

Not since Richard Feynman has a Nobel Prize-winning physicist written with as much panache as Robert Laughlin does in this revelatory and essential book. Laughlin proposes nothing less than a new way of understanding fundamental laws of science. In this age of superstring theories and Big-Bang cosmology, we're used to thinking of the unknown as being impossibly distant from our everyday lives. The edges of science, we're told, lie in the first nanofraction of a second of the Universe's existence, or else in realms so small that they can't be glimpsed even by the most sophisticated experimental techniques. But we haven't reached the end of science, Laughlin argues-only the end of reductionist thinking. If we consider the world of emergent properties instead, suddenly the deepest mysteries are as close as the nearest ice cube or grain of salt. And he goes farther: the most fundamental laws of physics-such as Newton's laws of motion and quantum mechanics -are in fact emergent. They are properties of large assemblages of matter, and when their exactness is examined too closely, it vanishes into nothing.

A Different Universe takes us into a universe where the vacuum of space has to be considered a kind of solid matter, where sound has quantized particles just like those of light, where there are many phases of matter, not just three, and where metal resembles a liquid while superfluid helium is more like a solid. It is a universe teeming with natural phenomena still to be discovered. This is a truly mind-altering book that shows readers a surprising, exquisitely beautiful and mysterious new world.


 for more information click here


Self-indulgent and offensive but absolutely wonderful

This book will probably offend you because of its *seemingly* flippant dismissal of various current popular theories such as string theory. The author comes across as arrogant, and the book is quite self-indulgently edited.

The good news is that it made clear to me, in a way that had never happened before, the depth of the problems facing naive reductionism. He shows how in many cases reductionist results have a high degree of bogosity. None of the solid states of water were predicted in advance, but after they were discovered "explanations" were readily found.

He convinced me that current "fundamental" physics is almost certainly no such thing and is almost certainly a set of emergent phenomena based on at least one more layer of physics.

The author's arrogance is tempered by the fact that he is quite happy to make fun of himself when this helps to make his point. Which is, in part, that the world is full of things we really don't understand and we need to be a bit more humble about it and accept the need to understand things on their own terms.

I would suggest that if you have read this book and did not have your understanding of physics and science generally radically changed, it might be worth reading it again and more carefully.

This is one of the best popular books on physics I have ever read and I highly recommend it.


 for more information click here


Why do they love it and hate it?

As with Wolfram's "A New Kind of Science", this is a book with valuable philosophical insights, which many reviewers dismiss because those are not physical insights. Hence the mix of 5 and 1 star reviews. In other words, don't come here to learn physics, but if you like "why" questions, then read this book.
A book that makes people angry is not necessarily revolutionary, but revolutionary books do make people angry.


A Very Funny Book...

... and deliberately provocative, as several other reviewers failed to realize. If I were a good deal younger, I'd describe Prof. Laughlin's humor as "snarky", but since that adjective isn't yet in my vocabulary I'll have to go with "sm*rt-*ssed". It's perhaps a sort of humor that tickles the funny-bones of science nerds most, rather like 'viola jokes' amongst us musicians, and the anecdotes almost certainly offend those readers who find they are the butts of Laughlin's humor. He is unrepentantly scornful of those he perceives as fools. But how can you resist his description of String Theory: "a textbook case of a Deceitful Turkey, a beautiful set of ideas that will always remain just out of reach. Far from a wonderful technological hope for tomorrow, it is instead the tragic consequence of an obsolete belief system..." Yeah! I happen to think of String Theory, if I have to, as Sudoku for Metaphysicians.

The unifying theme of A Different Universe is that physical sciences have "stepped firmly out of the age of reductionism into the age of emergence." I won't attempt to parse that statement; it would be like giving away the end of a suspense novel.

There are also moments of homiletic wisdom to be found, sauced with humor. In his chapter about nuclear science vs. applied nuclear engineering (think Hiroshima), Laughlin writes: "... self deception has consequences. Most of the time the effect is not as dire as warfare, but simply a degradation of the quality of life. These degradations include such happy institutions as road rage, divorce court, and excessively long faculty meetings." Make of that sermon what you will! It's not unamusing to find a Nobel-winning tenured professor at Stanford still picturing himself as Peck's Bad Boy or James Dean.

Geneticists should be warned that Laughlin is particularly harsh about their methodologies, even though he grudgingly admits that his kind of physics is a good deal more like biology than like the physics of yesteryear. Antone who has invested her/his retirement funds in nanotechnology will also have reason to cringe; Laughlin regards nanotubes as microcosmic black holes that swallow research money and never release it.

Proponents of "Intelligent Design" should be VERY careful not to leap to any assumption that Laughlin's ideas of emergent self-organization might support their beliefs. Quite the opposite: his Emergence utterly dispenses with any need, philosophical or scientific, for a Designer.

Much of what Prof. Laughlin writes, and writes about, will be cutting-edge difficult for many readers, but those readers will be hard-pressed to find a more engaging and comprehensible account of quantum mechanics, indeterminacy, the Standard Model, and other such items of bedtime reading than A Different Universe. Buy it for the jokes, and you may stay for the insights.


 for more information click here


reviews: page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7



products you might be interested in




recommendations

Readable and Plausible Books on Modern Basic Science
essential reading




reinventing


Reinventing the Right: Conservative Voices for the New Millennium
I Was a Really Good Mom Before I Had Kids: Reinventing Modern ...
Reinventing Your Life: The Breakthough Program to End Negative ...
New Job, New You: A Guide to Reinventing Yourself in a Bright New ...
The Elusive Fan: Reinventing Sports in a Crowded Marketplace



universe


The Elements: A Visual Exploration of Every Known Atom in the Universe
The Field: The Quest for the Secret Force of the Universe
The Fabric of the Cosmos: Space, Time, and the Texture of Reality
A Brief History of Time
Halo: Evolutions: Essential Tales of the Halo Universe



physics


Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman! (Adventures of a Curious Character)
Conceptual Physics Media Update, 10th Edition
Physics for Future Presidents: The Science Behind the Headlines
Physics of the Impossible: A Scientific Exploration into the World of ...
The Field: The Quest for the Secret Force of the Universe



search for books
bottom, different, physics, reinventing, universe



Google      toavi.com    web
books
apparel
baby
beauty
books
camera photo
classical music
computers
dvd
electronics
gourmet food
health personal care
kitchen
office products
outdoor living
computer video games
popular music
software
sporting goods
tools hardware
toys-games
vhs
watches jewelry







we recommend


Pop Fiction. At its best.

randomly chosen


book: Martian Quest: The Early Brackett